Ice fishing background

Fish•Fishing Near•Cayuga, Indiana

Fishing Spots Near Cayuga, Indiana

Top Fishing Spots Near Cayuga, Indiana

8 results
Mill Creek Lake

Mill Creek Lake

A high-pressure lake supporting numerous bass tournaments. Most fishing is for bass and crappie, leaving the walleye virtually untouched. 811 acres
Size
733 acres
Access
Trailer Accessible Boat Launch
Amenities
ADA Parking
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieLargemouth bassMuskellungeStriped BassWalleyeWhite bass
Learn more about Mill Creek Lake
Lake Freeman

Lake Freeman

The best fishing here is before Memorial Day and after Labor Day due to the high recreational use. The current state record white bass and hybrid str...
Size
1,569 acres
Access
Paved Boat RampTrailer Accessible Boat LaunchCarry-In Boat LaunchGravel Boat Ramp
Amenities
ParkingToiletADA Parking
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieFlathead catfishLargemouth bassSaugerSmallmouth bassStriped BassWalleyeWhite bass
Learn more about Lake Freeman
J.c. Murphey Lake

J.c. Murphey Lake

This entire lake, except for the ditches, is thick with weeds. Find an opening and you'll find a fish. Quality bass available.
Size
799 acres
Access
Paved Boat RampTrailer Accessible Boat LaunchCarry-In Boat Launch
Amenities
ADA ParkingParkingToilet
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieLargemouth bassNorthern pikePumpkinseedSmallmouth bass
Learn more about J.c. Murphey Lake
Lake Shelbyville

Lake Shelbyville

Crappie are the main attraction on this big Corps of Engineers impoundment. Walleye are a seasonal factor. Excellent facilities for camping, access an...
Size
10,235 acres
Access
Trailer Accessible Boat Launch
Amenities
ParkingToilet
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieFlathead catfishLargemouth bassMuskellungeSaugerSmallmouth bassSpotted bassStriped BassWalleyeWhite bass
Learn more about Lake Shelbyville
Lake Clinton

Lake Clinton

This large cooling lake supports a diverse fishery, featuring largemouth, catfish, walleye and hybrid stripers. Crappie and bluegill provide plenty of...
Size
4,586 acres
Access
Trailer Accessible Boat Launch
Amenities
ParkingToiletADA Parking
Species
Blue catfishBluegillChannel catfishCrappieFlathead catfishLargemouth bassPerchPumpkinseedSmallmouth bassSpotted bassStriped BassWalleyeWhite bass
Learn more about Lake Clinton
Monroe Lake

Monroe Lake

Indiana's largest lake and home to a trophy bass fishery. Crappie are abundant and attract a lot of attention. A quality catfish population is widely ...
Size
11,113 acres
Access
Paved Boat RampTrailer Accessible Boat Launch
Amenities
ParkingToiletADA Parking
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieFlathead catfishLargemouth bassPerchSmallmouth bassSpotted bassStriped BassWalleye
Learn more about Monroe Lake
Braidwood Power Plant Cooling Pond

Braidwood Power Plant Cooling Pond

Largemouth, catfish and crappie provide most of the action. Flooded strip pits offer interesting structure.
Size
2,540 acres
Access
Trailer Accessible Boat Launch
Amenities
ParkingADA Parking
Species
Blue catfishBluegillChannel catfishCrappieFlathead catfishLargemouth bassPumpkinseedRock bassSmallmouth bassStriped BassWalleyeWhite bass
Learn more about Braidwood Power Plant Cooling Pond
Bass Lake

Bass Lake

This shallow lake is home to nice walleye, channel cats, white bass and white crappie. Slip bobbers seldom go below five feet.
Size
1,436 acres
Access
Trailer Accessible Boat Launch
Amenities
ADA ParkingParkingToilet
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieLargemouth bassNorthern pikePerchPumpkinseedSmallmouth bassWalleyeWhite bass
Learn more about Bass Lake

Fishing Spots

30 results
Chew Lake

Chew Lake

Size
8 acres
Learn more about Chew Lake
Collett Pond

Collett Pond

Size
26 acres
Learn more about Collett Pond
Coffing Brothers Lake

Coffing Brothers Lake

Size
11 acres
Learn more about Coffing Brothers Lake
Shell Lake

Shell Lake

Size
2 acres
Learn more about Shell Lake
Lake Holiday Hide-away

Lake Holiday Hide-away

Size
76 acres
Learn more about Lake Holiday Hide-away
Georgetown Reservoir

Georgetown Reservoir

Size
0 acres
Learn more about Georgetown Reservoir
Westville Lake

Westville Lake

Size
5 acres
Learn more about Westville Lake
Herschel Lake

Herschel Lake

Size
18 acres
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieLargemouth bass
Learn more about Herschel Lake
Painter Lake

Painter Lake

Size
9 acres
Learn more about Painter Lake
Rice Lake

Rice Lake

Size
2 acres
Learn more about Rice Lake
Hemlock Lakes

Hemlock Lakes

Size
19 acres
Learn more about Hemlock Lakes
Woodland Lake

Woodland Lake

Size
2 acres
Learn more about Woodland Lake
South Hemlock Lake

South Hemlock Lake

Size
10 acres
Learn more about South Hemlock Lake
Horseshoe Lakes

Horseshoe Lakes

Size
32 acres
Learn more about Horseshoe Lakes
Rockville Lake

Rockville Lake

Size
81 acres
Access
Paved Boat RampTrailer Accessible Boat Launch
Amenities
ParkingToilet
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieLargemouth bass
Learn more about Rockville Lake
Doughnut Pond

Doughnut Pond

Size
8 acres
Learn more about Doughnut Pond
Highway Pond

Highway Pond

Size
7 acres
Learn more about Highway Pond
Lake Vermilion

Lake Vermilion

Size
793 acres
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieFlathead catfishLargemouth bassSmallmouth bass
Learn more about Lake Vermilion
Peelman Pond

Peelman Pond

Size
5 acres
Learn more about Peelman Pond
Lakeview Estates Lake

Lakeview Estates Lake

Size
3 acres
Learn more about Lakeview Estates Lake
Missionfield Pond

Missionfield Pond

Size
3 acres
Learn more about Missionfield Pond
Deep Pond

Deep Pond

Size
2 acres
Learn more about Deep Pond
Skyline Lake

Skyline Lake

Size
9 acres
Learn more about Skyline Lake
Hidden Pond

Hidden Pond

Size
1 acres
Learn more about Hidden Pond
Number 6 Lake

Number 6 Lake

Size
8 acres
Species
BluegillCrappieLargemouth bass
Learn more about Number 6 Lake
High Pond

High Pond

Size
6 acres
Learn more about High Pond
Sugar Mill Lake

Sugar Mill Lake

Size
35 acres
Learn more about Sugar Mill Lake
Long Pond

Long Pond

Size
27 acres
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieLargemouth bassNorthern pike
Learn more about Long Pond
McDonald Lake

McDonald Lake

Size
5 acres
Learn more about McDonald Lake
Clear Pond

Clear Pond

Size
21 acres
Species
BluegillChannel catfishCrappieLargemouth bassMuskellungeRainbow trout
Learn more about Clear Pond
Find more lakes near you in the onX Fish App