Mazatzal Peak Loop

We started from the Barnhardt Trailhead at 4:26 PM. The trailhead is 5 miles off the highway on a gravel forest service road. The parking lot is large and flat. You can opt to start the loop on the Barnhardt Trail #43 or the Y Bar Trail #44. We started on the Barnhardt Trail #43 trail which is well marked and mostly rocky. In some places, the trail is very rocky and tough especially if you are wearing light weight shoes. This area had rain the week before so the usually dry creek was full of water but off the trail. There was only one water source, and it was this creek, off the trail, down a canyon. Also due to the rain, wildflowers and cactus were in bloom making a beautiful sight in the desert. Since we got a late start, we needed a campsite before sunset. We were rewarded with the only viable place to setup a tent about 3.6 miles in on the trail. This site was right on a cliff overlooking the valley below, the Mogollon rim and Paysen. (34.0923deg N, 111.454deg W)The next day, we set out from our camp at 7:30 for water and another campsite. The hike on this part of the Barnhardt Trail #43 was a narrow brushy path which was very tough to hike through. We followed the contours towards the intersection of the Arizona Trail (AZT). On our map there was a trail shown that rolls down towards the creek but this was blocked and looked like it hadn't been used in many years. When we reached the trail intersection with the AZT, there is one trail on the map that is missing at this intersection. We went south, left, on the AZT and immediately we were on a wide and well defined trail. Hiking south, we again stayed on the contour heading towards the Mazatzal Peak. The trail at time was narrow but not brushy. On the way, we saw lots of manzanita blooming and rocks of all shades including red, purple, yellow, and blue. This area has big veins of quartz running through the cliffs which are evident along the Mazatzal and across from where we camped. We came accross an AZT through-hiker just at the beginning of the ascent at the base at Mazatzal Peak. He started at the border and was going to finish at Flagstaff. We reached a saddle and saw that we had to hike just below the steep ridge and ascend up to another saddle. This portion of the trail became narrow and brushy. I am not sure if horses could traverse this section. Once we reached the saddle, we searched for a listed spring but there was no water. We then joined the Y Bar Trail #44 which would turn out to be a very troublesome trail. We couldn't find water at the last 2 marked water locations so we decided we had to make it back to the trailhead. This last 4 miles was downhill on a rock trail with large rocks, no switchbacks, and a very difficult base. By the end of the hike my feet were sore. The Y Bar Trail #44 might be scenic but you couldn't tell since you had to be watching the trail right in front of you due to the rockiness and not wanting to lose your footing.I don't know that I would hike the Y Bar Trail #44 again. The Barnhardt Trail #43, however, was very nice in comparison.